If you’re still blaming the algorithm, this one’s for you. Instagram’s algorithm isn’t out to get you, it’s just bored. And right now, attention spans are shorter than a TikTok clip. Translation? ‘Posting to post’ is officially dead.

Here are the five mistakes I see killing engagement every day; and how to flip them into growth moves that actually work right now.

---

❌ Mistake #1: Posting Without a Hook

The scroll is brutal. If your first 3 seconds (or first line of text) doesn’t stop someone, you’ve already lost.

👉 What’s not working: “Happy Monday 🌸” captions, generic stock photos, or Reels that take 10 seconds to get to the point. Nobody cares.

👉 What does work: Hooks that create curiosity or tension. (Example: “Your content isn’t flopping because of the algorithm. It’s flopping because of THIS.”)

⚡ Current Reality: TikTok and Reels both reward watch time. If you don’t grab attention immediately, your post won’t even leave your bubble.

---

❌ Mistake #2: Playing It Too Safe

Safe = invisible. The “professional but boring” approach used to get you polite likes. Now it gets you silence.

👉 What’s not working: Corporate-sounding captions, Canva templates that look like everyone else’s, zero personality.

👉 What does work: Opinions. Hot takes. Humor. A little edge. People engage with people, not brands.

⚡ My rule: If I write a caption and it feels too safe, I scrap it. The posts that do best for me (and my clients) are the ones that make people feel something.

---

❌ Mistake #3: Ignoring the Platform Shift

Every platform is shifting right now:

• Instagram is pushing Reels + carousels. Static posts are on life support unless you’re a meme page.

• TikTok is rewarding longer (30–60s) storytelling, not just trends.

• Threads is giving organic reach to people who are funny, bold, or brutally honest.

• Facebook is… well, still Facebook, but Groups + Stories are the sleeper hits.

👉 What’s not working: Copy/pasting the same content across every platform.

👉 What does work: Respecting each platform’s current “language.” Post the same idea, but in the format that fits.

⚡ Example: I can take one idea → make it a controversial thread, a talking-head TikTok, and a carousel breakdown on IG. Same thought, three different languages.

---

❌ Mistake #4: Posting Inconsistently (or Just to Fill Space)

Consistency isn’t about posting daily, it’s about posting with a clear rhythm people can rely on.

👉 What’s not working: Posting three times one week, disappearing the next, or throwing up filler content that adds zero value.

👉 What does work: A repeatable system. For me, batching content (shooting once a week/month for 30 days of posts) → then mixing it up (Reels, carousels, threads) keeps things consistent and creative.

⚡ Current Reality: Platforms are rewarding consistency + retention. If you ghost, you fall out of favor fast.

---

❌ Mistake #5: Forgetting to Actually Talk to Your Audience

Engagement is a two-way street. If you’re not starting conversations, you’re just shouting into the void.

👉 What’s not working: Long motivational rants with no CTA.
👉 What does work: Simple, interactive questions. “Agree or disagree?” “Would you try this?” “What’s your #1 struggle with ___?”

⚡ What I’m doing that works: I treat captions like an open door. The more I ask, the more my audience talks back, and the algorithm loves that.

---

💡 Final Word: Stop Blaming the Algorithm

The algorithm isn’t your enemy. The algorithm is a mirror! If your content is boring, safe, or confusing, it won’t push it. If it’s bold, valuable, or fun, it will.

Stop playing it safe. Say the thing. Test the idea. Be the person people want to stop scrolling for.

Not sure why your content feels flat? That’s exactly why I created my Pick My Brain call. A 60-minute 1:1 where we find your blind spots and build a clear action plan. Book your session here → Pick My Brain 🧠